It’s time to talk transparently about AI

And to do that, you need to: Understand, Audit, Disclose, and Control.

Lately, I have been deep diving on AI governance – the ways in which organizations, institutions, and governments can control the outputs and impacts of AI-enabled tool usage. It’s gotten me to work with three notions:

1 / what new tech mental models are required for these times?

AI isn’t a monolith, it’s a kind of analytical and productive tool, and there’s a material difference – like a 100x factor – between aggressive frontier model development, and a private instance of an LLM. There’s not a lot of nuance in the conversation. Some people are hard NO WAYs [22% of my ad hoc poll on instagram, itself a data black hole] and — trust me — LOTS of people are using AI without clear guidelines to transparently disclose. It’s a complicated technology with a giant ??? “we’re not sure how this works” ??? in the middle and lot of…

2 / Avoidance, shaming, and anger at both “the system” and “personally having to deal with this” looks a lot like money / capitalism feelings

I’ve been talking with people about topics they wish they didn’t have to mess with for YEARS. Trust me, I too wish I could safely skip understanding these systems: Money, Data Privacy, the next new technology … that’s not a safe choice for someone without independent economic means.

I’ve said it a thousand times about money: you don’t have to like it or approve of it to understand it. I think the same goes for AI and tech systems at large. There’s a ruleset you can learn, so you’re less vulnerable to the exploitations awaiting people who don’t understand and through which you can reduce unintentional harm and engage with discernment. Why not learn the rules?

3 / Self-lead governance is annoying, and necessary

Much like there’s a part of me that wants someone else to just make it all work out for me, and another part that deeply wants a world in which none of this is material, if I stop there and only revel in those desires, I know I will be operating in fantasy and not facing reality.

The fantasy: I can skip engaging in hard things, I can get a “gold star” by not touching the “bad” things

The error: focus on what’s too big to change as a release valve leading to skipping over what IS changeable.

The reality: focusing on finding and understanding specific things that can be controlled and decisions made about leads to taking actions to reduce one’s impact

For example: Focusing on how shitty capitalism is leads to avoidance, which leads to things like:

  • not auditing your spending and ending up more in debt and paying more money to credit card companies or,
  • not changing what your investments are invested in so they’re better [even if not perfect]
  • spending unconsciously / consumerism doomerism
  • not donating in line with your values

We really need guardrails that meet reality.

Without overwhelming ourselves, it’s time.

The video above goes into a framework you can – and I think should – use if you engage in any technology these days [and if you’re reading this on a computer, you engage].

Understand – AI is not a monolith, and developing LLMs, using a system, and using the outputs of an AI-enabled tool are different, specifically in both their impacts and what you can control in regards to your engagement with them.

Audit – take a real look at the AI-enabled search, bot “helpers”, chats, agents, buttons, and so on. Where is AI in your life, today?

Disclose – if an audit is self-disclosure, see if you can start to mention more when you’ve used AI [or managed to avoid it], to do what, as a way to get it out of the shadows. For those of us in business this is extra important from a data privacy and consent standpoint. I recently updated my data privacy and AI use policy on my website to this end.

Control – what you use, what you input, privacy settings, admin settings, what kind of trust you give to outputs, what bias you look for and add thinking to fix.

We also need discernment instead of shame.

There’s not an easy answer to the introduction of a technology that could be – is being – wildly misused and is misappropriating resources.

But.

That’s not a reason to avoid understanding and controlling it.

In my deep dive, I set out to understand the technologies AI consists of, how they’re used, what regulation is happening, what the open source hacker types we like are doing with AI, and how regular people who aim to responsibly try to use their everyday digital tools might do so.

I ended up taking a Harvard course on AI governance. Governance is the ways in which organizations and institutions [and to an extent, individuals] combine values, policy, and oversight to be transparent and mitigate the outputs and impacts of AI-enabled tool usage. The gist was: upfront definition of values and ethical principles, and red lines on data privacy and inherent bias can create guardrails on use of AI tools to help people mindfully control and monitor their use. To do this, everyone’s going to need more insight into what they – or those around them – are accidentally or intentionally using, to what ends.

The goal is to generate informed transparency so we don’t inadvertently add negative impact, and monitor for any impact we do have.

Transparency

I’ve been talking with funders, nonprofits, policymakers, small business owners and individuals and the range of takes has been illuminating. There are organizations that would surprise you using some AI tools, many considering what they might use, and a lot of uncertainty about how to proceed. (ps: this is why I started consulting on how to create AI governance).

In the video, I invite you to start to audit when you’ve used AI [or been able to avoid it], as a way to get these practices out of the shadows. For those of us in business this is extra important from a data privacy and consent standpoint. I recently updated my data privacy and AI use policy on my website to this end. I will certainly continue to evolve my policy and practices as technology and any use on my end expands.

As with money, practices of self-disclosure are going to take some norming around and there’s going to be a period of bumpy awkwardness. But: without disclosure, we’re missing the chance to really examine what we’re doing, say what we’re NOT doing, and offer consent to others.

If I taught a class about how small businesses can self-govern their AI use, would you want to know about it? Contact me to let me know!

So where are we? 

Complex ideas are getting so simplified that conversations are tough. AI is shoved in so many places it’s hard to discern how to not use it in some cases [try turning it off in your Google search]. Shame, anger, confusion and judgement are flying around.

In short, there’s disagreement on fundamentals: should AI development be allowed to run free [I think NO] or governed? Should its infrastructure be built [We’re $1T in with projected $10T upcoming]? How should any people be using any of this tech, if at all? 

In the private sector, good people facing AI are making waves on ethical, inclusive development, and writing on how to avoid cognitive surrender whilst still using it. Those focused on limiting environmental impact are leading many local campaigns to control data centers. In the public sector, while US federal regulation is scarce, NYC’s city council proposed a 10-bill package to regulate AI, following California. Various NGOs are formulating state policies to follow-on post midterms.

Where I’ve landed.

I have a brain that likes nuance and can untangle topics people tend to oversimplify: I study money, group decisions, history, and have built technology for a long time. The longer I pondered acknowledging and understanding AI, the more I am seeing a relationship to capitalism and money: we can’t control what we don’t understand.

I’ve talked about wicked problems – entangled and sticky issues without simple answers and we’re facing one now. I can’t tell you in good conscience to never touch AI, because if you google search, use social media, or have a job that makes you, it’s unrealistic. So: facing reality means we have to think critically.

I am also a longtime movement technologist, where we like to say “No technology is neutral” and this one is no exception. Most tech can have valid, human-centered, reasonable uses. It’s also true that – like with money – no tech tool is inherently bad; it’s that evil, bias, and inequality come out in both system design and individual uses. AI tools are both: potentially useful, and well positioned to exacerbate systemic problems.

Especially while we in the US linger waiting for useful government regulation to catch up to the tech, ways in which organizations, individuals, and institutions can understand and limit the outputs and impacts of AI-enabled tool usage is a good starter strategy. It just can’t be where we stop.